Wikiup:Projektdiskussion/Oskar Ernst Bernhardt
Dies ist eine archivierte Unterseite der Seite Wikipedia:Projektdiskussion. Wenn du die untenstehende Diskussion reaktivieren willst, dann binde statt der Vorlage:PRD-Diskussionsthemakopf/Archiv am Anfang dieser Seite die Vorlage:PRD-Diskussionsthemakopf ein und trage anschließend diese Unterseite wieder auf der Hauptseite ein, indem du dort am Ende die Zeile
|
Could someone review the changes at Oskar Ernst Bernhardt? They are not visible for unregistered users. I added the only three independent reliable sources from the article. Thanks. (I don't speak German.) Tgeorgescu (Diskussion) 00:51, 5. Nov. 2016 (CET)
To be sure, there are other independent reliable sources mentioned, but they are not in any way employed. Tgeorgescu (Diskussion) 00:56, 5. Nov. 2016 (CET)
As far as I know, inside Wikipedia if you have sources, you have everything; if you have no sources, you have nothing. And that was the situation of the article beforehand: there were several sources named, but they were not used. So, I have used six reliable sources written by competent scholars of religion (historians, sociologists and theologians). So, if somebody reverts my contribution, the article will be left barren: no source being used in any way, all the information will be original research performed by people who care one way or another about Abd-ru-shin, some of them may even have a conflict of interest, because they are too close to the subject, religiously speaking. And frankly, I have employed one of the sources already mentioned in the bibliography, so my action cannot be too bad, one might say. If I made grammatical errors, you are welcome to correct my text. Tgeorgescu (Diskussion) 23:56, 5. Nov. 2016 (CET)
The German language source which I added was written by Lothar Gassmann, so taking his notability at face value, there is nothing wrong with this source either. Tgeorgescu (Diskussion) 00:23, 6. Nov. 2016 (CET)
